Best 2 Slice Toasters and Toaster Ovens in 2018

Best 2 Slice Toasters and Toaster Ovens in 2018

We’ve spent hours researching the best 2 slice toasters that gathered the most positive reviews and provide the best bang for the buck, and here they are.

In this list you will find the top 5 models that are selected to help you decide what are the features you need, the pros and cons of each selection, as well as the price you can expect to pay for them.

While most people are specifically looking for a simple 2 slice toaster that browns the toast, we discovered you that can actually get a reputable 2 slice toaster and mini oven combo without breaking the bank.

Let’s take a look at the most well-loved selections for this category. Some families prefer larger appliances that can serve more people at the same time, and here’s the recommended 4 slice toasters that cut your preparation time in half.


Top 2 Slice Toasters and Toaster Oven


You don’t have to pay a lot for products in this category, simply because they are designed for the simple purpose of toasting a quick breakfast or reheating your bagels in a jiffy.

Even though there are a multitude of selections out there, these 5 models will provide the best functionality and reliability for daily use.





Price Range

   Hamilton Beach 22708 Toastation 2-Slice Toaster and Mini Oven  4.1 / 5  $
   Cuisinart CPT-320 Compact Stainless 2-Slice Toaster  4.0 / 5  $
   Hamilton Beach 2 Slice Cool Touch Toaster  4.0 / 5  $
   Hamilton Beach 22464 Cool-Touch 2-Slice Toaster  3.9 / 5  $
BLACK & DECKER TR1200SB 2-Slice Toaster, Stainless Steel 3.8 / 5 $


1. Hamilton Beach 22708 Toastation



Hamilton Beach has a few strong contenders in the 2 slice toasters and toaster oven category, and Hamilton Beach 22708 is one of their finest products. With close to 2,000 positive reviews on Amazon and a high rating, you can’t go wrong with this model.

Unlike the other selections in this list, the Hamilton Beach 22708 Toastation incorporates a mini oven at a very small premium over the other models (which are simply 2 slice toasters). It’s one-of-a-kind as there are no models (except for its sister model Hamilton Beach 22720 Toastation) that offer the same functionality currently.




Measuring at 16″ x 9″ x 8″, the Hamilton Beach 22708 takes up a small corner of our counter space. It is also highly portable with its light weight of only 8 pounds. The toaster on top fits 2 bagels or 2 pieces of toasts at a time, while the mini toaster oven comes with a tray that fits up to two 16″ pizza slices.

prosExtra Wide Top Slot

Instead of separating the top toaster slot into 2 like many others, the Hamilton Beach 22708 features a single, wider slot to provide more versatility. It can fit 2 slices of toasts, 2 bagel halves, or a longer hot dog bun at any given time.

prosMode Selector

The mode selector lever allows you to switch between toaster and oven mode with ease. Slide right to activate the top toaster slot, and slide left to use the convection oven at the lower compartment.

prosElectronic Toast Shade

The Toast Shade selector lets you select and change toast shade each time. The toasts produced are browned evenly and achieved even toastiness throughout.

prosFirm Bread Lifter

The bread lifter holds the breads and bagels firmly in place with a click. It feels solid and reliable, and there wasn’t a hint of wobbliness.





The main advantage that Hamilton Beach 22708 holds over its competitors are its versatility and affordability. By paying just $10 to $15 more, you get a full-fledged toaster oven compartment that is not available in any other toasters in the list.

Even when we were comparing it against other toaster ovens, few models provide this level of affordability and reliability.


Easy Cleaning

The Hamilton Beach 22708 features a slide-out, removable crumb tray at the bottom compartment to allow for easy cleaning. The crumb tray catches food debris that fall during toasting, and you can easily shake the crumbs away once you have removed the tray. The oven rack and baking pan provided are also dishwasher-safe.

prosAffordable Price

Few toaster ovens are priced in the $30 to $40 range, making Hamilton Beach 22708 one of the few models that provide the best bang for your bucks.

prosQuick Preheat and Cooking

Thanks to its compact size and powerful heating elements, this little toaster oven requires a very short time for preheating, making it very efficient when it comes to cooking or heating food in short period of time.

prosSpacious Interior (for its size)

Despite the compact exterior dimension, the interior of the convection oven is spacious enough to fit 2 slices of New York-style pizza just fine. It seems like Hamilton Beach has listened to customers’ feedback, improving on the oven’s height so it can even cook a whole potato with no issues.


What Could be Better?


consLack of Interior Light

This model does not come with oven light and automatic tray-eject, which may disappoint some potential customers. It’s designed to be an affordable, fuss-free and versatile cooking machine, so it’s not surprising that it comes with only the essential features.

If interior light is important for you, you may consider placing a small torchlight in the kitchen to illuminate the interior when required.


Bottom Line: Hamilton Beach 22708


It is an affordable toaster and toaster oven hybrid that fulfills the basic functions of toasting and cooking. With a compact size of 16″ x 9″ x 8″ and light weight of 8 pounds, it is highly portable and can be used in a kitchen or even a dorm room. If you are looking for something unique, this is quite possibly the best 2 slice toaster and toaster oven combo you can find in the market right now.


2. Cuisinart CPT-320 Compact Stainless 2-Slice Toaster



The Cuisinart CPT-320 is a compact and light weight little toaster, just like the name suggested. If the classical culinary design is your liking, you will like the blending of stainless steel and black painted steel of this toaster.

One interesting feature that comes with this model is the defrost setting, which is designed to first defrost, then toast your bread. Using this setting will extend the toasting cycle slightly, and it comes with several settings:

Settings 1 – 2: For refrigerated breads and thinner frozen items such as frozen pancakes.
Settings 3 – 4: For toaster pastries, frozen waffles, French toasts (thin), and refrigerated bagels.
Settings 5 – 6: For thicker frozen items such as bagels, hand cut bread, and thick French toasts.

They work pretty well as the end results are very similar to the toasts you would get if you toast them from room temperature.




Measuring at 6.5″ x 11″ x 7″, the 2.6 pounds Cuisinart CPT-320 toaster is equipped with a 900-watt heating element to ensure sufficient heat is delivered in the shortest period of time. The amount of wattage provided is standard for a toaster of this size, only the bigger 4 slice toasters are equipped with higher wattage, such as 1800 watt.

prosWide Toasting Slot

The toasting slots located at the top of the toaster measures at 1 and half inches wide, enough to fit thicker toasts, bagels, frozen pancakes, toaster pastries and English muffins.

pros6 Settings Shade Dial

A dial is used to set the toast shade of your preference. There are 6 settings available:

Settings 1 – 2: Light shade of toast
Settings 3 – 4: Medium shade of toast
Settings 5 – 6: Dark shade of toast

prosMultiple Toasting Functions

Instead of relying on just the shade dial to customize your toast, there are 3 preset functions to cater to the more common activities – bagel, defrost and reheat.

Bagel: Heats the upper half of bagel only for a crispy top and soft, chewy bottom. Use shade dial if you want your bagel to be crispy on both sides.
Defrost: First defrost then toast frozen bread.
Reheat: Reheats toast/bread without browning or burning it.
Cancel: Stops all toasting operations.




Cuisinart has not forgotten to include some thoughtful, nifty features to make this model a standout among all the other options out there. Apart from defrost and reheat settings, these are the functions that we liked:

prosHigh Lift Lever

Sometimes the bigger size of your toast/bread may prevent it from popping clear out of the toaster. Cuisinart CPT-320 incorporated a High Lift Lever that allows the user to boost the lever upwards, thus lifting the bread out of the unit for easy removal from the toaster with your fingers. This function came in handy when our freshly toasted, thick French toast was stuck in the toaster slot.

prosRemovable Crumb Tray

A removable crumb tray is located at the bottom to catch falling food debris. Just pop the bottom tray out and shake the crumbs away before installing it back. When the unit is not in use, you can also coil your power cord at the bottom for easy storage.


Long Warranty Period

As with other products of Cuisinart, the Cuisinart CPT-320 comes with 3 years limited warranty (which is longer than the standard warranty period of 1 year for most other brands).


What Could be Better?


consStainless Steel Exterior Can Get Tarnished Relatively Quickly

Customers who have used the toaster for a long time (more than 2 years) reported signs of tarnish on the brushed stainless steel exterior, especially if you are working in a humid kitchen. If your toaster comes in contact with water vapor often, it may lose its sleek exterior shine within 1 to 2 years of use.


Bottom Line: Cuisinart CPT-320


As a highly affordable toaster that toasts evenly and reliably, there really isn’t much to fault the Cuisinart CPT-320. If anything, the unit should be kept on a dry counter top to prevent the brushed stainless steel exterior from getting tarnished within the first years of use.


3. Hamilton Beach 2 Slice Cool Touch Toaster



Just like its name suggested, the exterior of Hamilton Beach 2 Slice Cool Touch Toaster remains cool even under operation. If you have little kids at home that may approach the counter top at any moment, this is the perfect model for safety considerations.

If you opt for the 4 slice variant, you will find the unique feature that comes in the form of independent toaster slots. You can operate just 2 slots at a time or all 4 slots simultaneously, and you can even use different settings on each set of slots simultaneously.

Live with your partner but like different toast shade? No problem, you can toast at the same time and use different toast shade on each set of slots at the same time. We tried using different toast shade on both sets of slots simultaneously and they came out just as we’d like it.




Measuring at 9.5″ x 13″x 8″, this Hamilton Beach model is a little bigger than the Cuisnart CPT-320 we have reviewed above. The weight is also slightly heavier at 3.4 pounds, but it’s not anything significant as they are already compact and light to begin with.

prosWide Toaster Slot

The top toaster slots are 1 and a half inches thick to fit thick bagels, waffles, English muffins and hand-sliced breads.

prosMultiple Preset Functions

The presets included are “frozen toast”, “frozen bagel”, and “bagel”. Do note that the toaster separates frozen toast and bagel as different modes because frozen bagels are defrosted first, and then toasted with higher heat to leave the bagels soft on the inside but crunchy on the outside. If you like your bagels crunchy throughout, you can use “frozen toast” mode instead.

prosAutomatic Toast Boost

This is nothing related to boosting the toasting time, but instead it is an elevated lever function that automatically raise the smaller contents (such as bagels or English muffins) up so they can easily removed from the toaster.


hamilton beach 2 slice cool touch



The Hamilton Beach 2 Slice Cool Touch Toaster is specifically designed with safety, functionality and reliability in mind. While most toasters are hot to the touch during operation, this model manages to stay cool even when we set it to the highest toast shade (setting 5) and toast several pieces of breads consecutively.

prosRemovable Crumb Tray

The removable crumb tray located at the bottom (image above) can be slid out easily to remove the food debris that falls to the bottom of the toaster unit.

prosCompatible Toaster Cover Product

Most customers who purchased the Hamilton Beach 2 Slice or 4 Slice Cool Touch Toaster also got themselves an affordable Ritz Quilted Toaster Cover for easy storage and carriage.


What Could be Better?


consShort Power Cord

The power cord for this unit is on the shorter end, but this is true for many other models as well for safety purposes. If your power socket is nowhere near where you want the place the toaster, invest in a heavy-duty power extension that is safe to support the heating elements.


Bottom Line: Hamilton Beach 2 Slice Cool Touch Toaster


This model is as affordable as it gets for a 2 slice toaster. If you have the space and needs, you may consider investing in a similar Hamilton Beach 4 Slice Cool Touch Toaster with just a bit of extra premium.


4. Hamilton Beach 22464 Cool Touch 2 Slice Toaster



Love bagels? The Hamilton Beach 22464 is the toaster to get if you toast bagels way more often than anything else.

With its extra-wide slots, it’s designed to accommodate your bagels without losing any of the sesame on its surface. Unlike some other 2 slice toasters that are bound to scrape the surface of thicker bagels, the Hamilton Beach 22464 ensures that all the goodness remain on your crisp bagel surfaces.

If you prefer to toast some longer breads (such as hotdog buns) occasionally, it also comes with an extra-long slots variant to accommodate your needs. Out of popular demands, Hamilton has also introduced the Hamilton Beach 24444, which is essentially the same toaster but with 4 extra-wide slots.




Measuring 7.4″ x 11.9″ x 8.5″, the Hamilton Beach 22464 is a little smaller than the Hamilton Beach 2 Slice Cool Touch Toaster, but still bigger than the mightily compact Cuisinart CPT-320. It weighs just 3.2 pounds, which makes it easier to be moved around the kitchen counter top if need be.

The exterior of the toaster is clad with black plastic, which in our opinion helped with its cool temperature. While it doesn’t look as premium as the Cuisinart CPT-320 reviewed above, we noticed that it is cooler to the touch, even when it is toasting bagel at the darkest shade setting.

This is ideal for families with little kids at home who can reach the toaster at the counter top.

prosBagel, Defrost and Cancel Functions

The Hamilton Beach 22464 is extremely easy to operate, with just a knob and 3 buttons indicating a Bagel, Defrost and Cancel functions. Even though the toaster is renowned for toasting bagels, you can still use it for breads and buns. Simply turn off the Bagel function and your toasts will come out evenly toasted on both sides.

prosDedicated Bagel Feature

The Bagel preset function is used to regulate different heat intensity and distribution on both sides of the bagel, toasting the cut side and simply warming the round side. Remember to switch this function off if you are toasting breads and buns, or they will come out unevenly toasted on both sides.

pros7 Shades Selector

The turn knob allows for 7 different shades of darkness for your regular toasts. The toaster does not use higher temperature to achieve darker shades, which means that the shades are controlled with varying toasting time. Expect to wait for a little longer if you prefer a darker shade for your toasts.





The Hamilton Beach 22464 excels as a simple 2 slice toaster that doesn’t break the bank. Being one of the most affordable options in this list, it gets the job done just like you would expect a basic toaster.

prosCool Touch Surface

There’s a merit to using plastic over stainless steel for the exterior surface. Even though it may not look as premium as some other models, it remains cool to the touch even when it’s operating under full load.

prosRemovable Crumb Tray

A removable crumb tray is located at the bottom to catch falling food debris. Just pop the bottom tray out from the back and shake the crumbs away before installing it back.

prosToast Boost For Toast Removal

Toast Boost is a lever that lets the users lift slices of toasts and bagels and take them out from the toaster easily. Admittedly, even though the body of the Hamilton Beach 22464 stays cool during operation, the top part is bound to be scorching hot, so the toast boost is a welcomed feature to boost up smaller pieces of toasts.


What Could Be Better?


consPlastic Smell During Initial Use

During the first few times of usage, you may notice a plastic smell when you are toasting. Typically, the smell goes off after 3 to 4 cycles, so the best way to get rid of the smell is to use a piece of bread and set it to toast at the darkest shade. Repeat the process 3 to 4 times until the smell has completely dissipated.


Bottom Line: Hamilton Beach 22464 Cool Touch 2 Slice Toaster


Built with affordability and practicality in mind, the Hamilton Beach 22464 excels at what matters, even though it goes without all the bells and whistles like stainless steel exterior and fancy preset controls. If you toast a lot of bagels, this model is an ideal choice over the other options considering its excellent bagel preset.


5. Black & Decker TR1200SB 2 Slice Toaster



A finely curated list of best 2 slice toasters isn’t complete without an entry from the household brand Black & Decker. It is well-known that Black & Decker excels at building quality kitchen appliances, and the TR1200SB is their attempt at the compact, 2 slice toasters category.

Like the Hamilton Beach 22464 reviewed above, the Black & Decker TR1200SB comes with two extra-wide slots to accommodate thicker toasts and bagels. However, it is equipped with a few extra features at a small price premium over the basic Hamilton Beach 22464 entry.





Measuring at 11.8″ x 7.9″ x 8.7″, the Black & Decker TR1200SB weighs 4 pounds, which is a little bigger and bulkier than the Hamilton Beach 22464 reviewed earlier.

However, if you are someone who values aesthetics highly, you will be happy to know that this model comes with a stainless steel exterior that is easy to wipe clean.

prosElectronic Toast Controls

The electronic presets feature Bagel, Frozen, Reheat and Cancel functions. Remember to switch off the bagel function if you want to toast breads or English muffins, as Bagel mode uses different temperature on both sides of heating elements that may result in uneven toast shades.

pros7 Shades Toast Selector

If you are toasting breads, you can use the shade selector to achieve the darkness you want on your toasts. In our few trial runs, the toast shades are pretty consistent and even. Other users have also reported similar performance.

prosBack-lit Function Selectors

The electronic toast control buttons are back-lit with red light to help you navigate the 2 slice toaster in a dark kitchen. Only the active mode (Bagel, Frozen, Reheat or Cancel) is lit up to help users determine which mode is currently being used.





With a stainless steel surface, most people would expect the 2 slice toaster to run hot during its operation. What surprised us was the cool exterior temperature even under full load, which is not something we can say about all toasters with a metal surface.

prosExterior Stays Cool

Even when sporting a stainless steel exterior, the Black & Decker TR1200SB 2 slice toaster is cool to the touch during operation. Beware of the metal piece at the top, though, as it is inevitably hot for any toaster under load.

prosAuto Eject Crumb Tray

While most crumb trays of budget 2 slice toasters have to be manually pulled out, the tray of TR1200SB can be ejected with a gentle push. There are 2 separate trays, one for each of the toasting slots. Interestingly, we barely noticed any crumbs at all even after several rounds of toasting, which means the extra-wide slots are doing a good job of not scraping the toasts at all.

prosRetractable Power Cord

One of the most unique features of the Black & Decker TR1200SB is the ability to retract its 33″ long power cord. There is not button to retract the cord, instead the power cable retracts itself as you pull it out. As a result, there is no extra cable to be seen, except for the minimally required length to connect to the power socket.


What Could be Better?


consPotentially troublesome if it breaks down

Black & Decker requires the users to cut off the cord and send it back to them before a warranty can be honored, which means you will be out of toaster for a week or two if you require a replacement unit.


Bottom Line: Black & Decker TR1200SB 2 Slice Toaster


Apart from the potentially troublesome replacement procedure, the TR1200SB is one of the best 2 slice toasters that have garnered plenty of good reviews over the years. Apart from the warranty procedure, there isn’t anything else to fault the otherwise awesome little toaster.


I hope you found the article useful. Be sure to check out our top picks for toaster ovens that represent the best bang for your bucks.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *